|
Is it Real? Review the Information and Decide for Yourself. Note: This site is NOT affilated with the company which produces Pherlure cologne.
But not Pherlure's di-dehydroepiandrosterone. This link goes to a Medline search for di-dehydroepiandrosterone, and shows the result:
Since it's not in Medline, di-dehydroepiandrosterone has never been mentioned in any published article or study. Pherlure claims they have a study showing that their product works, but we can no see that no such study was ever published. So is this a real chemical?
There isn't an easy way to link to ChemIDplus Advanced for a search, but you can search it yourself by clicking this link: ChemIDplus Advanced Search
We can't find any evidence that di-dehydroepiandrosterone is a known chemical, or that any study was ever published, but did the study happen at all? According to Pherlure, a University study took place at University of Chicago (well, that's what they say now. They used to say it took place at University of Illinois at Chicago, a public institution that has no connection to the private University of Chicago).
This student page, now deleted, was on a University of Illinois at Chicago web server. But it says that the study was done at University of Chicago. University of Chicago is a private University that has no connection with Universtiy of Illinois at Chicago - a public state school that just happens to be in the same city.
And this is the only place any reference to this study is found on any University web page. Do you believe a study really happened based on a deleted student web page? But how about the other sites that mention it?
Using Google, we can check to see what pages are in a site. In the case of ihealthjournal.com, the only pages were articles about di-dehydroepiandrosterone:
They have added a few more pages in an attempt to look legitimate, but there's still nothing much there:
Google pages listing for ihealthjournal.com
Note that this site currently claims the study happened at University of Illinois at Chicago, which is also what Pherlure says on their site.
Click on this link to display an archived copy of Pherlure's site (via Archive.org), from April 21, 2005.
As you can see, it says:
But apparently someone at University of Illinois at Chicago got angry that Pherlure was making these false claims, so they told them to stop. And sure enough, Pherlure changed BOTH sites so that they now both say the study happened at University of Chicago (which, as we mentioned before is a totally different school).
here's the link to the current version of the ihealthjournal page, showing University of Chicago.
More oddness: It claimed the di-dehydroepiandrosterone article was archived on Monday, February 07, 2005.
However if we looked at the domain name record for wondersinscience.com, that name was registered on Feb. 10, 2005 -- three days AFTER the date when the article was supposed to have been archived.
registration information for wondersinscience.com
What's going on here? We have a chemical which Pherlure claims is their active ingredient, but which we can't find any reference to in any published paper or database. We have a study which Pherlure claims validates their product, but it has no authors listed (and authors are always listed for any study), it was never published, and we can find it only on a deleted university page and on sites which seem to have no other real pages other than the articles about the study. And the sites can't even agree on whether the study took place at one university or another completely different one.
So what's going on? Decide for yourself whether to believe, in spite of the evidence, that Pherlure is a real product with a real ingredient and a real study that shows it works. Or believe the evidence and realize that Pherlure is none of those.
Note: Since this site was created, several pages have been added to ihealthjournal.com. These are the first pages other than the di-dehydroepiandrosterone articles to be added to these sites since they were created over a year before we published this site. The information we are presenting here was true when we first wrote it, and we have made no changes to the cached pages we are displaying.
We make no claims about what is true or false: we only present the facts, as verified by Medline and Google. Your decision about what is going on here is entirely up to you.
|